Two consoles, two 99s, two very different piles of reviews. On November 19, ActivePlayer.io found 156 critic reviews on the PlayStation 5 scorecard for Grand Theft Auto VI and 14 on Xbox Series X. Both displayed 99. That puts both versions alongside a score players have been bringing up for years — the one attached to the original Nintendo 64 release of Ocarina of Time.
The three 99s side by side
| Edition | Critic Metascore | Reviews listed |
|---|---|---|
| GTA VI · PlayStation 5 | 99 / 100 | 156 |
| GTA VI · Xbox Series X | 99 / 100 | 14 |
| Ocarina of Time · Nintendo 64 | 99 / 100 | 22 |
Read each row as a snapshot of that edition. The PS5 page carried more than eleven times as many reviews as the Xbox page when we checked. That gives you more individual verdicts to browse on PS5. It tells you very little about which console renders a particular street corner better. For that question, you’d want a reviewer who compared the two versions directly.
The Zelda entry is the 1998 Nintendo 64 game. The Switch 2 remake has a separate page and a separate review history. We covered the remake’s 96 launch score when that edition arrived. Keeping the editions straight matters more than declaring a winner from three identical numbers.
What’s behind the score? Start with the coffee table
In his Ars Technica review, Kyle Orland describes going from a violent deal to assembling furniture with his partner at home. The game registers the domestic chore as a moment in Jason and Lucia’s relationship. That small example tells you something a 99 can’t. If you enjoy the downtime between heists, Rockstar has given that time a role in the story. Orland also finds Jason less expressive than Lucia. A critic can admire the partnership and still have reservations about one half of it.
Game Informer’s review comes at the same rhythm from the city outside. Fishing off a boat, diving for treasure and noticing a stranger near an ATM are examples of how easily a trip across Leonida becomes a detour. The reviewer singles out the shift back into choreographed missions as part of the appeal. If your favorite part of GTA is abandoning the route on the minimap, read that account before scrolling through another dozen scores.
What to check when the number moves
Metacritic weights professional reviews and converts their scores to a common scale. A 99 can include reservations like Orland’s. It also sits apart from the user score. When you compare a screenshot with today’s page, check the platform, critic or user tab and review count. Combining the PS5 and Xbox counts would risk counting an outlet twice.
Want to see how Rockstar presents the game alongside those independent impressions? PlayStation’s official GTA VI feature is below. If the number you’ve seen is closer to eight million than 99, that’s another launch story entirely — our breakdown of the livestream audience explains who was being counted.








