Which score would you use to decide whether Grand Theft Auto VI is worth your weekend? On November 21, Destructoid observed a 5.6 out of 10 user score on Metacritic from 64,795 ratings. The PS5 critic Metascore was 99 out of 100. The New Zealand PlayStation Store listing we checked for this comparison displayed 4.82 out of five. Each figure tells you who chose to rate the game as much as it tells you how they felt about it.
Who gets counted on each scorecard?
| Scorecard | Launch snapshot | Where the number comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Metacritic critics, PS5 | 99 out of 100 | Professional reviews selected and weighted by Metacritic. ActivePlayer recorded this score on November 19. |
| Metacritic users, PS5 | 5.6 out of 10 | User ratings on the public scorecard as counted by Destructoid on November 21. Later submissions can move it. |
| PlayStation Store, NZ listing | 4.82 out of 5 | Star ratings on Sony’s storefront, checked November 22. The listing showed approximately 231,000 ratings. |
Destructoid’s report captured a specific moment on the PS5 user-review page. Our launch-day critic comparison preserves the separate PS5 and Xbox critic samples and explains the tie with the original Nintendo 64 release of Ocarina of Time. The two dates matter if you’re trying to reconcile screenshots from launch week.
Can a zero from a user lower that 99?
It goes into a different calculation. Metacritic’s methodology describes a weighted average of critic scores. The site explicitly excludes user votes from the Metascore. A new user rating can move the audience score while the critic number stays exactly where it was.
The storefront filters for a different group again. PlayStation’s reviews policy describes feedback on digital games players have acquired through its store. You can see the star distribution on the New Zealand product listing. A storefront rating still comes from someone who decided to leave one. Even hundreds of thousands of ratings don’t make that group a random sample of everyone who played.
What supports the review-bombing claim?
Destructoid reported finding accounts with little other reviewing history among the extreme scores it examined. That observation helps explain the controversy. It doesn’t establish how many ratings were coordinated, who organized them or what any individual player thought. A low number can also come from someone who spent hours in Leonida and disliked the pace.
If pacing is what could make or break the game for you, read a concrete example before choosing a side. ActivePlayer’s critic breakdown follows two reviewers from small domestic interactions to structured missions. Their descriptions give you something to compare with the way you like to play. Converting all three scores to percentages would still leave that question unanswered.








